Systems Management

I created a new queue and label yesterday. If I use one of our old labels, the email generates for the new queue properly. If I use the newly created label, it does not notify me when I create a test ticket. It does notify the other queue owners, however. If another queue owner creates a ticket, I receive an email. It's only when I create the ticket myself that I do not receive a notification. It's not a huge deal, but this works in our other queues, and I'm not sure what I have missed. 

Essentially:

L1 (previously created, original label) - If I create a ticket, I still receive a notification that a ticket was created in a queue in which I am an owner

L2 (newly created label) - If I create a ticket, I do not receive an email notification that a ticket was created in a queue in which I am an owner

L1 - If someone else creates a ticket, I receive an email notification that a ticket was created in a queue in which I am an owner. The ticket submitter receives a notification, as well.

L2 - If someone else creates a ticket, I receive an email notification that a ticket was created in a queue in which I am an owner. The ticket submitter, however, does not.

I'm not sure if the issue is in the queue settings, because if I change the label to a previously created one (L1) the emails generate. However, there isn't very much to creating labels, so I'm not sure what I could have missed there. Clearly I have missed something, I'm just not sure where it is. Any help would be very much appreciated!